| Catches | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1, 018 | FE Woolley | 1906 to 1938 | 979 |
| 887 | WG Grace | 1865 to 1908 | 879 |
| 830 | GAR Lock | 1946 to 1970 | 654 |
| 819 | WR Hammond | 1920 to 1951 | 634 |
| 813 | DB Close | 1949 to 1986 | 786 |
| 784 | JG Langridge | 1928 to 1955 | 574 |
| 764 | W Rhodes | 1898 to 1930 | 1,107 |
| 758 | CA Milton | 1948 to 1974 | 620 |
| 754 | EH Hendren | 1907 to 1938 | 833 |
Note: The most catches by a current player is 668 by GA Hick (1983 to 2006)
